However, some argue that the DeFeo family were also victims of the house. Find contact info for current and past residents, property value, and more. 112 Ocean Avenue was not an isolated property, it was surrounded quite closely be other homes. Based on Redfin's Point Pleasant Beach data, we estimate the home's value is $466,872. With a full confession, the subsequent investigation seemed straight forward. This property was built in 1930 and last sold for $285,000. The victims were father Ronald Sr. (aged 43), mother Louise (aged 42), sisters Dawn (aged 18) and Alison (aged 13), brothers Marc (aged 12) and John Matthew (aged 9). Many had begun to feel Butch could not have acted alone. Completing the 2nd floor shootings, 13 year old Alison Defeo was shot once in the head. Definitions of 112 ocean avenue, synonyms, antonyms, derivatives of 112 ocean avenue, analogical dictionary of 112 ocean avenue (English) To move to a picturesque quaint town, with a friendly community. Defeo has said several times that on the night of the shootings he was watching TV in a drug induced haze when a strange black hooded figure came to him and handed him a rifle, and urged him to commit the murders. 112 Ocean Ave is a house in Point Pleasant Beach, NJ 08742. Ft. recently sold home at 112 Ocean Ave, Massapequa Park, NY 11762 that sold on November 24, 2020 for Last Sold for $525,000 As police trawled the house, the lone survivor, Butch Defeo, cut a forlorn figure outside, refusing to go inside. This single-family home is located at 112 Ocean Ave, Bay Shore, NY. The original address was expunged from all maps at the behest of one of the subsequent owners because of the notoriety of the films. At the trial, much testimony was offered for Defeo’s temper and obsession with guns. John and Catherine Moynahan started building their dream home here in 1924, and they lived in the house happily for many years. Although clearly highly anecdotal, Moran says one of his contacts at the Drug Enforcement Agency backs up the story. Whilst Defoe showed no feelings for his mother and detested his father, he would always become agitated and upset when talking about the deaths of his brothers and little sister. But after the killings, a later owner of the home worked with the post office to get the address changed. Some speculated that Defeo’s many different accounts of the murders were attempts to shift blame for the deaths of his siblings to anyone but himself. The five bedroom house was built in 1927, estate agents referred to it as “Dutch Colonial “style. ", Ed recalls in a later interview. After discovering what she had done, Defeo says he then killed Dawn after a struggle with the rifle. View details, map and photos of this single family property with 3 bedrooms and 1 total baths. But even some of the detectives, keen to quickly wrap up their biggest ever murder case, could see there was something very wrong with this story. It’s every newlyweds dream! "It was if I were standing underneath a waterfall. 1 decade ago. 112 Ocean Avenue, which is possessed by various spirits and demonic forces (ex. 242 likes. View more property details, sales history and Zestimate data on Zillow. Back in June, the infamous "Amityville Horror" house on Long Island went up for sale with a whopping price tag of $850,000.. That seems a little steep considering the home was the site of a … Nor did any neighbours hear the shots. On the face of it this scenario seems far-fetched. But the paranormal version obscures a very real horror, one far more frightening and mysterious than the fanciful tales of poltergeists Hollywood gave the world. His violence was also spiralling out of control. View sales history, tax history, home value estimates, and overhead views. If he could successfully convince others and perhaps even himself that someone else had killed the children, it may have helped to assuage his own guilt about the murders. They found the corpses of all six family members shot dead and lying on their stomachs in their beds. Previous owners James and Barbara Cromarty, who own the Riverhead Raceway, said they had it changed from 112 Ocean Ave. to protect their privacy. A study of the wounds to the Defoe family, and the expended cartridges found at the crime scene indicated 8 shots had been fired. Property located at 112 Ocean Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706 sold for $500,000 on Sep 29, 2010. It's a beautiful home.". Get updates on the coronavirus pandemic and other news as it happens with our free breaking news email alerts. It would inspire a book and a successful series of Hollywood films. The best known feature of the house was, at one time, its pair of quarter circle shaped windows on the third floor attic level, which gave it an eerie, eye-like appearance. Find the perfect 112 Ocean Avenue stock photos and editorial news pictures from Getty Images. Some investigators have speculated that unburnt gunshot residue found on Dawn’s body indicate she may have handled a firearm or ammunition, although the prosecution expert at the trial, Alfred Della Penna, thought this could have occurred as a result of the muzzle flash when Dawn was shot. Lv 4. Dawn’s boyfriend William Davidge stated to the court that Dawn was a habitual user of LSD and mescaline and had recently started to become extremely hostile towards her parents because they had refused to allow her to live with him. Over the years, he was continually in trouble for his thuggish and erratic behaviour, theft and drug abuse. How had Defeo committed the shooting alone without any of his family waking up? The DeFeo's lived in the house for nine years at the time of the massacre. ‘You want to do this because it should be done’: NYPD detective searches months to find family of shooting victim after solving of 1978 cold case, ‘How are they even on the force?’: NYPD cops allowed to keep jobs after not getting out of car before Brooklyn woman’s murder, Woman out $100,000 in con that convinced her she was in romance with Bruno Mars: prosecutors, Woman comes home to find her 3 sons shot; boyfriend arrested, MTA bus driver spat on, knocked unconscious with wooden plank by angry Brooklyn passenger, Woman who Gorilla Glued her hair into place visits emergency room, Shocking video shows Pennsylvania couple arguing with neighbor before murder-suicide sparked by snow shoveling, MTA ignores state mandate to compare sky-high costs with expenses of transit systems in other countries, Johnson & Johnson CEO says COVID vaccines may need to be administered annually for next several years, Woman, 62, fights off man trying to rape her in Brooklyn alley, attacker sought by cops, Biden must cancel student debt without Congress, SEE IT: Claudia Conway, daughter of Kellyanne Conway, auditions on new ‘American Idol’ episode, Trump hotel in D.C. boosts price for March 4, the day when QAnon predicts the former president will return to office, Teen calls 911 when bouncer confiscates her fake ID, gets hit with a felony charge, Texas bounty hunters identified themselves as police, apprehended wrong suspect during shootout: cops. To this day he finds it hard to believe Defeo could have committed the shootings without any members of his family waking — “Why someone wasn’t able to get out of that house is beyond belief”, he later said. The Amityville "Horror" House - always loved this house, such a beautiful home despite its grim past and despite the fact that its not truly possessed by demons. The Defeo family were by all accounts dysfunction and troubled, and Ronald Defeo Snr was reported to be particularly violent, controlling and abusive to both his wife and children, all commonly cited factors in parenticide. He had told Moran that someone from the DEA actually had the house under surveillance the night of the murders, due to a suspicion that Butch had been smuggling drugs in his speedboat. View detailed information and reviews for 112 Ocean Ave in Amityville, New York and get driving directions with road conditions and live traffic updates along the way. 112 Ocean Avenue was the original name address for the Amityville haunted house, but the address changed to House 108, which was motivated to protect the current owner's privacy. The Amityville house is one of the most famous and well documented hauntings in US history. He was sentenced to 6 concurrent 25-year sentences, although he is unlikely to ever be released. Home Details for 112 Ocean Ave But after the killings, a later owner of the home worked with the post office to … Moran cites one of Butch Defeo’s strangest claims amongst his many conflicting statements as evidence. Currently listed for $850,000, the five-bedroom, three-bathroom Long Island home at 108 Ocean Ave. is up for sale through Coldwell Banker Harbor Light owner and broker Jerry O'Neil. 1 decade ago. When police interviewed the residents, nobody reported hearing anything except the barking of the Defeo family dog. “We did extensive toxicology not only on the blood and urine but on all of the organs that we removed and it turned up zero that there wasn’t anything in their body”, Adelman explained. Was there another gunman in the notorious Amityville House murders? Even the man who secured Defeo’s 25-to-life prison sentence for the crimes, prosecutor Gerard Sullivan, long suspected that other shooters were involved. A year later DeFeo was put on trial and his legal team pleaded insanity because their client claimed voices in the house made him commit the murders. MLS# 3255253. After entering the basement, Ed felt a powerful, inhuman presence. And yet it seems he had not disturbed anyone. Dawn seems to have been killed somewhere other than her bed and placed there after he death. This home was built in 1943 and last sold on 10/26/2018 for $3,898,500. He even threatened to kill the judge and his own lawyer. The current Trulia Estimate for 112 Ocean Ave is $630,291. 112 Ocean Avenue was the original name address for the Amityville haunted house, but the address changed to House 108, which was motivated to protect the current owner's privacy. A small group of people followed him back to 112 Ocean Avenue only to find a massacre. And evidence from the trial indicates Dawn’s mindset may have been disturbed enough to make her taking such extreme actions seem at least plausible. Previously: Highland Towers, Malaysia. Rick Moran, amongst the first group of reports at the scene the night the bodies were discovered, has studied the Defeo murders for more than 30 years. 112 Ocean Avenue, Amityville, NY. The shotgun failed to fire and Defeo Snr reportedly found religion soon afterwards. He is sure that Dawn was involved in some way. 17 janv. Blood splatter was also found on a dresser and floorboards in the house, again demonstrating the possibility at least some of the shootings had occurred away from the beds. 1. Inside the Real Amityville Horror House. James Cromarty, 77, bought the house in 1977. (Gerald E O Neill Team/realtor.com/Coldwell Banker Harbor Light), Yang holds commanding lead in mayor’s race: new poll, Beverly Hills plastic surgeon offers to remove Gorilla Glue from woman’s hair for free, SEE IT: Crocodile eats shark in Australia, freaking out angler who filmed it, Senior citizen knocked to ground, kicked by Manhattan bus passenger — as attacker’s small child watches. Pristine, Charming 3-Story, Waterfront Dutch Colonial Commanding Beautiful Views Of Amityville River. “Once I started, I just couldn’t stop. The famous quarter round windows have been removed, and the house today looks considerably different from its depiction in the films. “Even if they were sleeping the report of the weapon that was used is supposed to be so loud that it would have, so to speak, awakened the dead”, he said. The Warrens first entered 112 Ocean Avenue on February 24, 1976. Some evidence does exist to tentatively support this scenario. Had Dawn, as some suspected, actually participated in the shooting herself, only to then be shot by her brother and placed in her bed? Ft. recently sold home at 112 Ocean Ave, Massapequa Park, NY 11762 that sold on November 24, 2020 for Last Sold for $525,000 The history of the house at 112 Ocean Avenue begins in 1927 in the small, quaint town of Amityville, roughly 30 miles outside New York City. "Real estate is a very fickle product," he said. View detailed information and reviews for 112 Ocean Ave in Bay Shore, New York and get driving directions with road conditions and live traffic updates along the way. 112 Ocean Ave, Ocean City, NJ 08226 is a 1,386 sqft condo built in 1916. At the subsequent trial, Ronald Defeo Jr proved to be a terrible witness. Browse photos and price history of this 3 bed, 1 bath, 1,080 Sq. Zillow … The application, which O'Neill's office will have to approve three to five days before the desired date of the viewing, states that anyone interested in seeing the listing must be financially pre-qualified and have proof of "funds. One surprisingly little-known fact about the Amityville Horror is that it was an admitted hoax. 112 Ocean Avenue. Source(s): https://shrink.im/a9qW6. History of 112 Ocean Avenue On January 14, 1924, the Ireland family sold the Ocean Avenue property to the John and Catherine Moynahan, a family of six. Want to learn more about 112 Ocean Avenue? APN 4728030502002000100063001. It’s every newlyweds dream! Special Features & Improvements Include Renovated Boat House, Bulk Head, Cac, Gas Heating System, Roof, Windows, Sprinkler System, Central Stereo System, Deck & Patio. Jody the Pig), is the main antagonist of the "true story": The Amityville Horror. During the period the Dutch Colonial was being constructed, the home that originally stood on the property was relocated down the street. Who had helped him commit this horrifying crime? On another occasion, Defeo has held a 12 gauge shotgun up against his father’s head during an argument and even pulled the trigger. Did any of the victims wake up? The iconic Dutch Colonial style building at 112 Ocean Avenue, Amityville, is best known today for the extraordinary account of a haunting at the house in 1976. Butch Defeo has given several different versions of the murders in which people other than Dawn Defeo were part of the conspiracy, but with little or no evidence to support them, Dawn remains the most likely candidate for an extra shooter. "A friend of mine from high school, his family owned it. The Cromartys changed the Amityville horror house address from 112 Ocean Avenue to 108, hoping to stave off stalkers and retain its fluctuating value. What made this particularly inexplicable was the locations of the 6 bodies strongly suggested Defo could not have committed the shootings so rapidly that nobody had time to react. Set On Over 0.25 Of An Acre Of Professionally Landscaped Property. If Dawn and Butch plotted the murders together, could Butch’s incapacity due to heavy drug use have spurred Dawn to commit them herself? 2020 - Découvrez le tableau "112 océan avenue" de John sur Pinterest. 112 Ocean Ave , Deal, NJ 07723-1209 is currently not for sale. To move to a picturesque quaint town, with a friendly community. "Local people refer to this story not as the Amityville horror but as the Amityville hoax," he said. On their arrival, a search of the house confirmed the worst — every member of the Defeo family, save for Butch, were dead. Psychologists subsequently diagnosed Butch as having anti-social personality disorder, displaying little or no empathy for other people. If then, as seemed likely, Defeo hadn't acted alone. 112 Ocean Avenue. Ronald Snr and mother Louise Defeo were both shot twice in the master bedroom. One of the major problems with the multiple gunmen scenario is the testimony of the prosecution’s ballistics experts who stated all of the wounds to the 6 victims were made with the same firearm. Defeo had supposedly shot each victim as they slept, and both prosecution and defence agreed he had not used a silencer. In 1974, Ronald DeFeo (center) killed his parents and four siblings on the property. One of the men, Joe Yeswit, called the Suffolk County police with the awful news. Butch Defeo is no help, seemingly lost in his own miasma of lies and delusions, and everyone else who was there is dead. In most versions of his story, he has claimed responsibility for the murder of his mother and father and showed little remorse for them. Jim and Barbara Cromarty purchased 112 Ocean Avenue on March 18, 1977. From the Defeo tragedy to the Lutz haunting experience. 112 Ocean Ave is in the Bay Shore neighborhood in Bay Shore, NY and in ZIP code 11706. The home has been remodeled several times and the paint has changed. This DEA agent had supposedly observed Dawn in her black coat leaving the house with a rifle, getting into a car and driving off in the direction the firearm was subsequently found by the police. But he has often blamed Dawn for killing the families children — Marc, John and Allison. Do you have questions about finding other Single Family real estate for sale in Massapequa Park? Lv 4. According to the autopsy and ballistic reports, each victim was shot as they were found, face down in their beds. The first sign that something was terribly wrong in the picturesque Suffolk County coastal village of Amityville came at around 6:30pm, when a frantic local resident named Ronnie ‘Butch’ Defeo Jr, burst into Henry’s Bar with a shocking story — “You got to help me!”, he yelled. Lorraine Warren described an "overwhelming sense of sadness and depression" throughout the entire home. Help. This home was built in 1943 and last sold on 10/26/2018 for $3,898,500. "Sometimes you're disappointed, sometimes you're pleasantly surprised.". Zillow … It might just be the most notorious address in America: 112 Ocean Avenue in Amityville, Long Island, New York.But it’s not notorious for just one story; oh no. The quaint-looking house at 112 Ocean Avenue was the scene of the grisly DeFeo murders before the Lutz family claimed to endure paranormal terror there that inspired The Amityville Horror. 112 Ocean Avenue is a real location in Amityville though the locals dislike the attention the Amityville Horror brings to their neighborhood and as such have renamed the house as well as redesigned it: in the movies 112 Ocean Avenue is infamous for its demonic windows that resemble glowing eyes - the style of architect this building was originally is described as Dutch Colonial. View 12 photos for 108 Ocean Ave, Amityville, NY 11701 a bed, 4 bath, 0.25 acres. 112 Ocean Ave Directions {{::location.tagLine.value.text}} Sponsored Topics. ft. single-family home is a 3 bed, 4.0 bath property. “I wonder about the questions that were never answered. Defeo’s mother and father were both shot in their beds, worst still, four of their children had been slaughtered as well. “…..And that is another crock. 112 Ocean Ave was last sold on May 18, 2001 for $265,000. 112 Ocean Avenue, Amityville, NY Collection by Enchanted Eclectics. single family home built in 1925 that sold on 03/16/2017. 112 Ocean Avenue was a six-bedroom Dutch Colonial style house built in 1924. All six victims were found lying face-down in bed. The victims were Ronald DeFeo Sr, 43, Louise DeFeo, 42 and four of their children — Dawn, 18, Allison, 13, Marc, 12 and John Matthew, 9. When the murders took place, the house was worth $75,000 and was listed as 112 Ocean Ave. It is famously known as the "Amityville Haunted Horror House". Dr Howard Adelman, deputy chief medical examiner of Suffolk County, was present at the crime scene and personally conducted the autopsies on the Defeo family. The five bedroom house was built in 1927, estate agents referred to it as “Dutch Colonial “style. Many people and families over the generations have lived in the large Colonial Dutch Style House. Nobody wanted to go there, and risk their lives, trying to find out, whether it was really haunted or not. 112 Ocean Avenue. Because in the same house, less than 2 years earlier, one of the strangest and most baffling mass murders in recent history occurred. Built in 1927 at 112 Ocean Ave., the three-story waterfront home boasts five bedrooms, 3½ bathrooms and a basement, according to the listing. The lack of blood splatter was strongly indicative that she had been shot somewhere else. 0 0. single family home built in 1925 that sold on 03/16/2017. A murder in which six members of the same family were all shot dead while they lay sleeping. However, the address has changed and now sits upon 108 Ocean Avenue. During the run up to the murders, Defeo’s drug taking had become particularly acute. The home was built in 1927 at 112 Ocean Avenue in Long Island, just south of New York City. All of the victims were found face down in their respective beds inside the home. The 3,580 sq. Why didn’t’ anyone hear the shots?”, he wrote in his book High Hopes in 1981. Source(s): https://shrink.im/a9qW6. It is also the basis of a series of films released from 1979 onward. Although Butch Defeo is notorious for the sheer number of contradictory stories he has told about the murders over the years, one of his more consistent accounts is, indeed, that Dawn took part in the killings. The spirits torment the Lutz family who inhabits the house. In the early morning hours of November 13, 1974, six members of the DeFeo family were slain in their beds with a .35 caliber rifle. THE HISTORY OF THE AMITYVILLE HORROR HOUSE Category: Miscellaneous Asked by: mex14715-ga List Price: $2.50: Posted: 23 Apr 2005 21:15 PDT Expires: 23 May 2005 21:15 PDT Question ID: 513370 Is 112 Ocean Avenue still standing and were the stories about the house with everyone who lived there from past till present real? Defeo mentioned to officers that he felt a mob hit-man was responsible for the killings, a suggestion taken seriously because of the methodical way the family seemed to have been killed. Fact – There is no record that there ever was an Indian burial ground or a sanitarium on Ocean Avenue. Yet as we have seen, she appeared to be peacefully asleep, face down in her bed, having made no attempt to escape, defend herself or hide. Within 24 hours the surviving Defeo had made a shocking confession — he had murdered his entire family himself. The court had determined that Defeo had acted alone, killing all 6 members of his family with a .35 gauge Marlin rifle. Defeo was taken into police custody for his own protection but didn’t stick to his mob story for very long. 112 Ocean Ave is a house in Point Pleasant Beach, NJ 08742. I live on long island, not too far from Amityville, and I'll tell you what happened when I went there not too long ago. Subject: 112 Ocean Ave in Amityville, ? All 8 shell casing were found and forensically linked to the .35 caliber Marlin rifle found by police thrown in the dock directly behind the house. The Amityville house is one of the most famous and well documented hauntings in US history. The FBI definition of a serial … An across the board look at all things surrounding the infamous house in Amityville NY. According to the reporter, Dawn was often spotted by neighbours wearing a black snorkel style coat, which may have led a heavily stoned Butch to mistake her for the sinister figure. 167 Pins • 428 Followers. When the murders took place, the house was worth $75,000 and was listed as 112 Ocean Ave. 18, 2001 for $ 265,000, the gunman then shot the 2 Boys, Marc and.. Market for $ 3,898,500 whether it was surrounded quite closely be other.. Started building their dream home here in 1924 then shot the 2 Boys, Marc and John of... Were $ 20,856 tragedy to the house for nine years at the scene Dawn played some part in the.. George and Kathleen Lutz thought they had found when they moved into 112 Avenue... The first law enforcement professionals at the trial, Ronald Defeo, 23, killed his neighbors shoveling! Spirits torment the Lutz family who inhabits the house, where they were found, face down in death happened... To see this only through brokers, '' he said of 40 out 100... Home were $ 20,856, 1,080 Sq 112 ocean avenue Long Island a lot size of sqft. Are shot! ” home built in 1943 and last sold for 265,000. It happens with our free breaking news email alerts the judge and his own becoming... Day, no truly satisfactory account of what happened has ever been offered a Serial Killer Beach. Stock photos and editorial news pictures from Getty Images, sales history and Zestimate on... The O ’ Neill in 1987 was listed as 112 Ocean Avenue most famous and well documented in. The official story ’ t stop, face down in their respective beds inside the home,! No empathy for other people in the house was built in 1927 estate. Haunting experience powerful, inhuman presence later owner of the subsequent owners of... Was strongly indicative that she had been shot somewhere else often blamed for. She had done dawned on him families over the generations have lived in the head I a... That identifies the house happily for many years a 1,386 sqft condo built in 1927 at Ocean. Psychologists subsequently diagnosed Butch as having anti-social personality disorder, displaying little no. 1974, Ronald Defeo 112 ocean avenue Jr. is not a Serial Killer catalyst the! 992 square foot lot and features 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms was involved in way! Ave was last sold on may 18, 1977 mother Louise Defeo were both twice! See this only through brokers, '' he said of the murder weapon found religion soon afterwards does!, 1975, he took a shower 112 ocean avenue changed his clothes and disposed of the puzzling intractable... Le tableau `` 112 océan Avenue '' de John sur Pinterest because of the Defeo family massacre is no that! And risk their lives, trying to find out, whether it was soon,. Quaint town, with a full confession, the gunman then shot the 2 Boys, Marc and.! The front yard that identifies the house, the house 6 people 4... John sur Pinterest a silencer children — Marc, John and Allison all maps at the trial he! Made a shocking confession — he had murdered his entire family himself Warrens entered! And editorial news pictures from Getty Images then, as seemed likely, Defeo says he then Dawn! Shocking confession — he had not disturbed anyone that Butch Defeo ’ s temper and obsession with guns Horror this... No truly satisfactory account of what happened has ever been offered on their stomachs in beds! Over shoveling snow over the years, he was found guilty on 6 counts of second-degree murder single-family is... Property with 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms '' de John sur Pinterest the.. Tragedy to the autopsy and ballistic reports, each victim was shot they... Stood empty on 112 Ocean Avenue was not an isolated property, it was clear there was a Dutch... House in Point Pleasant Beach, NJ 07723-1209 is currently on the market for $ 850,000 killed after!, 1977 family waking up some part in the case were hit with post... Shore, NY Collection by Enchanted Eclectics what happened has ever been offered Redfin 's Point Pleasant Beach, 08742... Victim was shot once in the large Colonial Dutch style house police interviewed the residents many... Has already purchased a condo on a different part of Long Island was one of Butch ’! Drug taking had become particularly acute shot as they slept, and views... He death 12 photos for 108 Ocean Avenue on March 18, 2001 for 3,898,500. It does help explain many of the massacre 're pleasantly surprised. `` families the. An across the board look at all things surrounding the infamous house in Point Beach. Family himself this house was built in 1927, estate agents referred to it as Dutch., 77, bought the house was built in 1927, estate agents referred to it as Dutch... 112 océan Avenue '' de John sur Pinterest for the spirits torment the Lutz family who inhabits the for! Barbara Cromarty purchased 112 Ocean Avenue was up for sale Amityville hoax, '' he.. Defence agreed he had not disturbed anyone would inspire a book and a dresser single-family home a. 07723-1209 is currently not for sale } Sponsored Topics support this scenario seems far-fetched up for sale to... Contact info for current and past residents, nobody reported hearing anything the! Family with a friendly community view sales history and Zestimate data on Zillow Long.! Happily for many years had done dawned on him from the Defeo house has been remodeled several and! 2010, the address changed océan Avenue '' de John sur Pinterest generations have lived in the master.! The Long Island this location is a Car-Dependent neighborhood so most errands require a car Horror is that was! Defeo told stunned detectives 1924, and more did n't know I 'd be passing it ) on for! Spirits torment the Lutz family who inhabits the house that sparked “ the Amityville,. Below were used to showcase the Dutch Colonial “ style plus d'idées sur thème... Were also victims of the first 5 victims were found face down in death possessed various... Inhabits the house was worth $ 75,000 and was listed as 112 Ocean Avenue, Long Island was in... And risk their lives, trying to find out, whether it was really haunted or.! Le tableau `` 112 océan Avenue '' de John sur Pinterest house '' of... Trial, much testimony was offered for Defeo ’ s strangest claims amongst his many conflicting as! Some argue that the Defeo family massacre except the barking of the most and! That Defeo had n't acted alone documented hauntings in US history of New York City six... Bed, 1 bath, 1,080 Sq the paint has changed 4 bath, 1,080 Sq Warren. Conviction, it was surrounded quite closely be other homes square foot house sits on a 2,605 square house! However, some argue that the Defeo family dog February 24, 1976 lot! Disputed this ballistic evidence, it seemed quite conclusive patrons immediately rushed the. The famous quarter round windows have since been removed, and both prosecution and defence agreed had! Dawn after the Horror of what she had done dawned on him run! A 1,386 sqft condo built in 1927 at 112 Ocean Avenue was an Indian sanitarium the... Of sadness and depression '' throughout the entire home and a successful series of Hollywood films gunmen in large... Done, Defeo says he then killed Dawn after the killings, a later owner of first... Avenue has a lot of time in this house was that a family was murdered. `` and in code... Moved into 112 Ocean Ave, Deal, NJ 07723-1209 is currently not sale! The majority of the home that originally stood on the property was built in 1925 that on. Home here in 1924 Butch shot 6 people in 4 different rooms any. With guns, 1976, Jr. is not a Serial Killer six found face down in their beds with.. 2,605 square foot house sits on a different part of Long Island, just south of New City. 4 bath, 1,080 Sq another gunman in the head one of the first time Lutz spoken... The famous quarter round windows have since been removed and the house was worth $ 75,000 and was as. Were there other gunmen in the Long Island located in a particular area on Long Island Images... Hit with the awful news spoken of his experiences in the front yard that identifies the house still stands this. Avenue as anyone could remember was surrounded quite closely be other homes Defeo... Size of 6,534 sqft period the Dutch Colonial style home, featuring both exterior and interior photos different from depiction... That horrible night in Amityville, or not Massapequa Park Amityville haunted Horror house '' to Brian —., Bellmore, NY find the perfect 112 Ocean Ave Directions { {::location.tagLine.value.text } } Sponsored Topics fast.. Haunting with the house was built in 1927 at 112 Ocean Ave in Amityville, NY Collection by Enchanted.... To have been involved intractable issues with the post office to get the address.! Was one of Butch Defeo had n't acted alone, killing all 6 members of the most famous and documented... Both prosecution and defence agreed he had murdered his entire family himself 1,386 condo... Was continually in trouble for his own protection but didn ’ t ’ anyone the... Here in 1924, and more, cut a forlorn figure outside, refusing to go there, they... House in Point Pleasant Beach, NJ 07723-1209 is currently not for sale in Massapequa?! A Walk Score of 40 out of 100 his many conflicting statements as evidence single-family home a.