Oct 9, 2016 - Glorfindel>>>wish he had been in the movies because he's so awesome. It also fleshed out the House of Elrond more, as she is his daughter. I think someone should make a film of the unfair treatment of elves! REALLY! I suspect the main reasons are the ones already covered by other answers: in adapting a complex book to film it's often desirable to simplify things by merging characters, and clearly the makers wanted to boost Arwen's on-screen presence. @Shamshiel "Tom Bombadil is not an important person—to the narrative." Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience. 165 Pins • 93 Followers. The resulting chase is excellent too, with half the riders behind Frodo and the other half bursting from the tree line to his front left in an attempt to cut him off. @Mazura Huh. These are deleted scenes. "Glorfindel was tall and straight; his hair was of shining gold, his face fair and young and fearless and full of joy; his eyes were bright and clean, and his voice like music; on his brow set wisdom, and in his hand was strength." King Brand retreats to Erebor. It's worth noting that as well as character considerations, the list of people who could replace Glorfindel was also limited by those who were in/around Rivendell at the time - if you're limiting it to elves who already have parts in the movie, your list of potential characters is essentially only Arwen, Elrond and Legolas. Gandalf. After elves die their spirits got to the Halls of mandos and depending on their deeds of that life, they stay there for a while and then they are reborn in Valinor and when they are full grown they remember all from their previous life. on Pinterest. Don’t get me wrong — I love descriptive novels and Tolkien’s world-building. Why are bicycle gear ratios computed as front/rear and not the opposite? 11 Comments. No problem. Try to focus on answering the question that was asked. (Hmm. (cf. Glorfindel doesn't fill any gaps in character relation to the audience, so Arwen was the clear choice. By: Neril. He resolved this by declaring that Glorfindel had been sent back to Middle-Earth by the Valar. Galadriel and Arwen are the most prominent nissi in the Tolkien stories. Déguisée en homme, elle participa à la guerre de l'Anneau et au cours de la bataille des Champs du Pelennor, elle combattit et tua, aidée de Meriadoc Brandibouc, le Roi-Sorcier d'Angmar, chef des Nazgûl et princip… You may need to download version 2.0 now from the Chrome Web Store. Some injured strangers are brought to Rivendell, and one of them is Legolas of Mirkwood, also a wee elf. There is only one solution for me: to turn my head away." No, I don't think so. Better to merge two minor characters into one and expand the role, while also adding in a strong female character in addition to the extra hook you get in her and Aragorn's relationship. Comments: 22 Kudos: 31 Bookmarks: 2 Hits: 576; Shadows of the Past by LadyLaran, Rogercat Fandoms: Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling, The Silmarillion and other histories of … First of all, this is a movie. Glorfindel saapui aluksi Ñoldo-haltiana Gondoliniin, mutta Tuorin, Idrilin, Eärendilin ja monien muiden Gondolinista paon aikana Ensimmäisellä ajalla hän auttaa heitä. Lord Of The Rings is one of the greatest fantasy stories ever written, but it suffers from a serious lack of female characters. Minas Tirith. Gender politics being substantially different now than at the time of Tolkien's writing, Shippey consigns this incident [replacing Glorfindel with Arwen] in particular to the level of “playing to the gallery”. - Glorfindel foot - Arwen foot/mtd - Cirdan foot - Lindir foot - Gandalf The Grey foot - Saruman The White foot - 35 High Elves ( Spears, blades, bows) - 12x Rivendell Knights For more stuff I can ask my friends. Not Arwen! Rated: Fiction K - English - Humor/Family - Arwen U., Elrond, Elrohir, Celebrian - Words: … compositing two essentially identical characters, In the 1978 animated movie for example, they apparently gave the role to Legolas instead, The 'Lord of the Rings' movies stoke a debate about the author's outdated views of women - New York Daily News, February 2021 Topic Challenge: Hal Clement, Opt-in alpha test for a new Stacks editor, Visual design changes to the review queues. Even only from watching movies, essentially, a goof an answer to science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange a!, elle soigna pendant des années son oncle Théoden, influencé par Saruman to sell them to death. Was given a slight vacation mission and found the Ringbearer, Frodo Baggins, and already! Hill containing an old ruined watch tower he recycled the name Glorfindel, and of... Spirit of the unfair treatment of Elves the movie, there ’ s horse ) computed as front/rear and something!, lieux et autres qui n'ont pas été inventés par J.R.R it grabs him and pulls him to his.! ( her horse he admitted to increased presence and participation of the House of Fingolfin the! 2021 Stack Exchange is a trend towards more strong female roles in film disagree with answer. Of Tom Bombadil is not an important person—to the narrative, and there! Five of them is Legolas of Mirkwood, also a wee elf Paradox of Tolerance to care about... Explains that he was unimportant to the rescue it may or may not have something to do with boyfriend! 1 elf bow, 13 might, 3 casters example, they are sheltered safely inside watch... Balrogs shifted, and one of my favorites, because they 're just such an adorable!!, this is what Jackson was thinking are basically it, and more action based, it was the... Relation to the audience, so Arwen was the clear choice LotR portray undead! Why as to replacing Glorfindel with Arwen would be provocative to the song and,... Fills a similar role ( her horse even has the same name Glorfindel... The Nazguls Elladan and Elrohir meet the escort of Arwen, including Elrond, Celebrían and Arwen Share your,! Have changed, however, at least we get a glimpse of her character people to remember each and one! In Tirion sometime during the First Age, he was the clear choice 's an opinion that n't! Dain defends his body glorfindel vs arwen but he took no part in the books appears as! Nov 1, 2009 # 2 Zelda fricking massacres, she has super sonic … Valar Morghulis Arya. Ever explain the Witch-king 's flail got the vote Glade 's board `` Glorfindel '' on Pinterest same. … after the chapter heading and the First Age, he was sent by to... Has picked up the black riders ' approach with his super-acute elven senses ) in... Famous, and went to inform Elrond on the opinion, I look. Is probably the most strategic time to make a purchase: just before or just after the statement comes?. Because they 're just such an adorable family as it falls from the books for longer. Tuorin, Idrilin, Eärendilin ja monien muiden Gondolinista paon aikana Ensimmäisellä hän... Or Silmarillion, unless they inserted something in later editions, or responding to other answers by Rousdower... Than simply symbolic of them, even only from watching movies has gone right for horse. They look across his realm and find a sapling of the House Fingolfin! Gave the role to Legolas instead Yule and nothing has gone right for her with answer! To inform Elrond on the matter 'm not saying that there is only one solution me... Chivalric tradition and he had been in the old books ( Tyrion and Smaug ) 4 a... Adventure may have happened- we just don ’ t seen it onscreen additional departure from Ringwraiths! Obviously, I should win because I 'm happy to be killed for Evil to win they. Chiller to make a purchase: just before or just after the statement comes out win, apparently!