Apply along lash line for super smooth glide, super pigment power and super all-day wear. Unless you don't mind your eye make up looking like a 7 year old drew on your eyes. Difficult to put on. This product is very soft and when trying to sharpen is clogs the sharpener due to the soft creamy texture. I find the color is soft on my eyes and easy to apply. I recommend that you place the pencil in the freezer for about 20-30 minutes before sharpening to get a really good point. Skip to main content.us. It is very affordable and looks great. Goes on smoothly. It's not sticky and doesn't make the lids feel stiff. Hello, I really like the pencil because the gel stays on all day no smear but this is the second time that I buy it and it doesn't last not even two weeks and a half the first time that that happened to me I thought it was a defect in the pencil but with this one it has happened the same thing I turned it and I turn it and it doesn't come out at all I'm not planning to buy it again , It's a pity because I used to like it very much! I do not look the changes that have been made to this product. What Else You Need to Know: This eye pencil ensures precise and gentle application, making it ideal for both lid and waterline application. Turn the pencil gently in sharpener 3 or 4 times, being careful not to apply excess pressure. This *was* the best eyeliner until they changed it. IT Cosmetics Superhero No-Tug Gel Eyeliner made me fall in love with eyeliner again! I LOVED this eyeliner. I used to LOVE this eyeliner. Complete waste of money. It glides on smooth without clumps and lasts all day. ULTA Gel Eyeliner Denim. This one doesn't go on easy or look good. I got a few for Christmas and am considering just throwing them away and going with a different brand. Maybelline eye studio lasting drama waterproof gel, smooth maybelline gel eyeliner pencil how to sharpen. Rosaria from Native NYer, bitterly living in NJ. The liner is fine, but now it's been 2 weeks and I have to throw it out. IT Cosmetics Superhero No-Tug Sharpenable Gel Eyeliner combines what you love most about Superhero Liner and your original No-Tug Anti-Aging Gel Eyeliner - making it easier than ever to achieve precise application without tugging on your delicate eyelids! Pathetic. I bought this liner because of the claims of how smooth it was and how waterproof it was. If you hate disappearing or traveling liner, please try this product! I love how smooth it glides on, its super easy to smug out for a smokey look and even though its glittery - it doesnt look childish. For starters, I have SUPER sensitive eyes and hooded eyelids. I refuse to waste another cent on this. It catches the light so well and creates a stunning yet daily look. I love how smooth the application is. hours, is the gold-standard. However, I will be looking for a new eyeliner on my next purchase. The color choices are great and the liner went on easily. (ulta.com) have been adding this to my color options regularly. This type of eyeliner often comes in a small jar, and is applied with a brush. asked on January 8, 2016. Debating on buying something new. What it is: A long-lasting eye pencil, now available in a mini format at a mini price. I can't believe how stupid this product is. it last long and goes on smooth!! Rated 1 out of 5 by Fromuk from As others have stated, please bring back the Original No Tug Eyeliner. Maybelline New York Eyestudio Lasting Drama Waterproof Gel Eye Pencil, Cashmere White, 0.04 Ounce. It should come out of the freezer harder than it was before. It doesnt twist up...just use the ulta sharpener! I now waste over half the product having to sharpen a pencil that feel impossible to sharpen to begin with and is so uneven gliding on that it hurts my eyelids. Gel eyeliner is a long-lasting eyeliner that creates a dramatic and noticeable effect. Share your best tips and tricks for sharpening your eyeliners! I will repurchase this again. Superhero No-Tug Sharpenable Gel Eyeliner, This item is not eligible for coupon discounts. I got the black color, the only reason I gave 4 stars is that after I apply the liner, the color on my bottom line ends up having a blueish tint, not a true black color. Ulta Gel Eyeliner was the first gel liner that I decided to try. All you get is the tiny amount of product you see and there's no way to sharpen it so it just becomes a nub you have to throw out after like 4 uses. I do not understand this product at all. Shakezula the mic ruler from Poplar bluff mo. It will NOT come off with face wash. This new applicator, which you have to sharpen, does not apply as well. I got these during a buy 2 get 2 free sale at Ulta but I don't think they are really worth the … More than 600 five-star reviews for less than $3? Every other liners either smudged, ran, or wore off within a few hours. Sharpens eyeliner tip to a point for precise application. Tbougjt it must have been defective, but then saw other reviews reporting the same thing. Great eyeliner for the first few uses, but then it's done. Sorry for the (possibly) dumb question, but I am stumped, and Google is not my friend on this search. I have not once pulled or forced the pencil! I got this in bronze and plum, and I love them both. The staying power makes this amazing if you line your waterline too. With Summer heat in full swing, I’ve needed to edit my makeup routine to favor more long-lasting formulas. If you haven’t used it yet there is no reason to sharpen this, unless you want a finer point. To use: Insert tip of eyeliner pencil into the sharpener and rotate it against the blade to shave to a point. The finer the brush, the more control you'll have with the makeup. You cannot tight line with this. Raccoon eyes within the hour of applying. Then, no matter what I do, my lids get very oily. This will NOT sweat/slide off during the day. I bought a new sharpener to go with them. This did not wear well on me. Great product by it Cosmetics! No Tug. Hey pretty gals; today’s pick is a gel eye liner from ULTA named Denim. Also, half of the pencil is eaten up with the sharpener. This eyeliner is just as good as any high end eye liner! Take the pencil and apply along the lash line or in the inner rim in short strokes. Barose also loves this liner for its smudgy, pigmented finish but acknowledges that sometimes, gel liner can get a little too soft, making it hard to sharpen it … The pencil is impossible to sharpen. I promise, it's not leaving your face until you want it too! The edges are jagged and sharp, the eyeliner goes on VERY smudged. So I bought the Endless Silky Eye Pen from Target for $14 and I assumed that it would be twist up or SOMETHING since the pencil body itself is not wooden and cannot be sharpened. Very disappointing considering the price tag. liner is nice and smooth. Very disappointing. I bought this liner to use as a softer day look that i was able to smudge out or use in water line. I have used it cosmetics for the past 2-3 years and have loved them. Better than my UD 24/7 pencil BY FAR! eyestudio lasting drama gel pencil eyeliner maybelline waterproof url? I think this eyeliner is a good deal since it combines brightness and easily glides on for the price. But, do you notice how they don't offer a sharpener with it or even one for purchase? I absolutely love this eyeliner! I was so disappointed. Sooo disappointing! If you have hooded lids, you need this liner! It works so good, and is very inexpensive. I normally use the Ulta Automatic Eyeliner in Black/Brown because I've always preferred a crayon-style application versus a pencil. At the moment we have three standard shades. So you can use it for a few days and then it's useless. There's nothing worse than trying to sharpen your favorite eyeliner and having it destroyed. This was stored in a makeup drawer as always without excessive heat. So, recently I bought a few gel eyeliner pencils on crazy sale at Sally Beauty Supply. Pretty grey color. TattooStudio Sharpenable Gel Pencil Longwear Eyeliner Makeup is Maybelline’s longest wearing eyeliner yet. Showing 1-10 of 12 answers. I absolutely love the colors and the ease of application. This gel liner has been a staple of mine for years - as the retractable version - and now I'm going to have to change to another brand given the new sharpenable version that no one asked for now being on shelves. I used to use the taupe color, which has been discontinued. Never used gel before. Change it back! This one was perfect and I was thrilled to finally have a worthy eyeliner. So disappointing. I haven’t returned it only for the fact that I love the quality of the eyeliner itself. Too expensive for this to happen. I tried both versions of Ulta's eyeliner and had the same results. This pencil would not sharpen. This was my GO TO eyeliner. Black Out: Cyclopentasiloxane, Synthetic Wax, Isododecane, Polybutene, Hydrogenated Cottonseed Oil, Simmondsia Chinensis (Jojoba) Seed Oil, Ceresin, Ozokerite, Microcrystalline Wax, Tocopherol, Ascorbyl Palmitate. I can't seem to find any pencil to line my bottom lid that doesn't run. Goes on smooth but not sharpenable. IT Cosmetics: Bring back the old style and I will be more than happy to buy your product again. No matter what sharpener I use, it is jagged, uneven and all around, unusable. I feel really stupid because there MUST be a way. Ulta beauty. I have green eyes and it makes my eyes pop! I have spent a lot of time looking at this thing and I cannot for the life of me figure out how to sharpen it/extend it. Good for a week. For best results, don't forget to sharpen with your favorite cosmetic sharpener! You sharpen Urban Decay eyeliner by using a plastic cutter. For some reason people dont understand that you can sharpen this pencil with a sharpener. Because they know too! I can easily put near my lash line which has been a great help!! It is covered in wood, and works excellently. May Contain: Iron Oxides 77491 / 77492 / 77499, Ferric Ferrocyanide 77510, Mica 77019. We hope you get the perfect ulta eyeliner from the above list. They first time I used it, I loved it! Now it's "sharpenable" which isn't true. Perfect timing for the new Revlon So Fierce Vinyl Eyeliners to land on my desk! Ulta's Gel Eye Liner Pencil is a super creamy, pigmented gel eyeliner pencil that provides effortless smooth application and lasting pigmented coverage. Great eye pencils. Doesnr roll up at all. Thanks IT. Ulta's Gel Eye Liner Pencil is a super creamy, pigmented gel eyeliner pencil that provides effortless smooth application and lasting pigmented coverage. Honestly, I'm so completely IN LOVE with this liner! o Featuring technology exclusive to IT Cosmetics, this waterproof and sharpenable gel eyeliner pencil gives you super smooth glide, super pigment power, and super all-day wear. This *was* the best eyeliner until they changed it. When removing my makeup, I had tiny clumps of this liner that were very hard to remove. The So Fierce eyeliners just hit stores and are supposed to deliver up to 16 hours of waterproof wear with bold pigmentation and a shiny vinyl finish. I will not buy it anymore until they bring back the retractable version that doesn't require sharpening. Amazon.com : Ulta Beauty Gel Eyeliner ~ Copper : Beauty. I agree with many others. Revlon So Fierce Vinyl Eyeliner ($7.99) is hew long-wearing glossy waterproof eyeliner that launched in several shades in the UK several weeks ago and are now just popping up in drugstores here in the US. Very saddened by the changes. I was excited about using the espresso eyeliner. Is this a joke?? Now it's "sharpenable" which isn't true. Almost completely gone by the end of the work day. I wear waterproof mascara daily, so it all comes off together. Q webcache. The metallic shimmer would look awesome with an over the top make-up, but who does that during the pandemic? A single blade eye pencil sharpener designed for When Pencil Met Gel Long-Lasting Eyeliner. This is one of my favorite eyeliners so far. It is the best eye liner ever. I use a good makeup remover to get this product off- no tugging though! Sharpen your eyeliner pencils once a week to get rid of surface dirt or bacteria and to keep the point sharp. See, Super blendable gel eyeliner pencil delivers smooth-glide application of rich, saturated color without tugging on your delicate eyelids, Available in 8 high-impact shades for your most eye-opening results. It is no longer an eyeliner that has a retractable feature. I loved the color on my lash line. I use the pencil, then set my brow with Loreal’s Brow Stylist. Makeup & Beauty Tips on How to Sharpen Your Eyeliners. I loved this product and hope IT sees all of these bad reviews and brings back to original eyeliner. I will save it for a backup. Look no further than Ulta’s eponymous option that’s only $8. Then they went and changed it and now it is basically unusable. Would 100% buy again and its now in my everyday make up routine. For best results, keep your pencil sharpened with Ulta's Cosmetic Pencil Sharpener ! Most eyeliners I have to fix and redo during the day, but this one looks just as good at the end of the day as it did at the start of the day. I've bought this one since i got a sample in a ulta pack. For starters, I love that you don't have to bother with messy sharpeners. I even bought a new sharpener, same issue. BUY NOW ($8) Ulta Essence Long-Lasting Eye Pencil. Half of my eyeliner is eaten up trying to sharpen it. Ulta Gel Eyeliner Pencil. I have been wearing this eyeliner for years. Ophthalmologist tested. Will never get it again. Color -1 + Add to Cart Quick view. Ridiculous to pay this much for a product that lasts less than 2 weeks. 2 The Point Double-Ended Eyeliner. (This is quite important because I'm doing EVERYTHING I can to minimize wrinkling!) For really soft/creamy pencils, put them in the refrigerator or freezer to help them harden to minimize waste. On top of that, I absouletly can't stand taking time to get a look down, then looking in the mirror 3 hours later and all my hard work is gone. Which, I have not done with an eyeliner since my high school days. I do not have dry or mature eyelids, and this was difficult to draw on. And because the color is so pigmented, I don't need multiple passes! Putting your eyeliner in the freezer before you sharpen it will prevent it from crumbling when you try to sharpen it. I love this eyeliner but I have to say I hate that it's not a twist up and that it has to be sharpened. This particular sharpenable pencil is not like any I've had. What Else You Need to Know: Unprecedented intensity in just one swipe.This gel-like formula glides on with comfortable ease, instantly depositing rich color that's blendable, then sets exactly where you want it for up to 12 hours. When it comes to drugstore versions, this one, which stays put for up to 24 (!) Temptalia’s Tips. They need to bring back their old eyeliner. Prior to finding IT No-Tug liner I had tried just about every eyeliner out there and this was by far the best. The color/s are STUNNING! Great product for the price. Tried the sharpener on a drug store brand pencil and it worked. Just wish the plum color was more noticeable, This is a very very long lasting liner! I've bought 2 pencils so far because I was not able to sharpen them! Stays put and the peacock color is awesome. This liner has the absolute BEST staying power out of any I have ever used! Gives a beautiful soft look to the eyes.l am 72 and feel pretty when I have the liner on. Beauty & Personal Care Hello, Sign in. I realize this is likely a tactic by the company to sell more pencils but based on these reviews, this will likely backfire. I've tried it several times and this has happened every time. I was upset when it cosmetics changed their no tug gel eyeliner, and decided to give this one a try. This eyeliner used to be retractable, not a pencil that needed sharpened. Answer. I will never use another brand again this is my favorite! Bring back the old product. If you have difficulty getting a straight line of eyeliner on your eye, consider sharpening your eyeliner pencil prior to use. I definitely won't but this brand again, but I won't throw out this eyeliner either. Yet, in recent years, I've found that this type of application isn't as easy anymore (perhaps with age) and I've struggled through various brands to find something that will mimic how my eyeliner used to look. The second time, it broke off. IT Cosmetics No-Tug Waterproof Gel Eyeliner: rated 3 out of 5 on MakeupAlley. It blends and smudges better than any other liner or gel I have ever used! Not at all what it used to be. Way too much product wasted for the price. Complete waste of money. Why would you package an eyeliner that is impossible to sharpen? That is where the positives end. The wood just shattered and the pencil kept breaking. “I recently bought an ulta gel eye liner pencil and fell in love. While the color is still good, and it goes on easily, this is only the case for about two weeks. Feel free to share your experiences, how you mastered techniques, or what you struggle with. Goes on smooth but it's just dark brown, not even close to a plum color. I have one in my car, just for emergencies, but for sure lasts all day! How do you sharpen the maybelline lasting drama waterproof gel pencil. It is HORRIBLE. I used it after applying foundation, blush, and contouring using an angled eyeliner brush. Loves how pointed it was how it just guides on. Ophthalmologist tested. Say no more. Not pigmented enough. I tried three different types of sharpeners and none worked. I have tried them all, this is the only one that doesn't disappear throughout the day. OMG! I would reccomend 100x over! And it is Not sharpenable, as it says. It sharpens up nicely. Rather you need to sharpen it. Goes on smooth but does not stay put on my oily skin. Rookie question: How do you sharpen Rimmel ScandalEYES nude eyeliner? Highly recommend! It does not twist up and it's next to impossible to sharpen. See 36 member reviews and photos. Ulta says this Gel eyeliner pencil is super creamy, pigmented gel eyeliner that provides effortless smooth application and lasting pigmented coverage. It is not a bad product, however it good have a better brush for the gel side. I'm legit obsessed! Or you could just switch to Mac eyeliner. It is amazing, goes on so smooth and stays on great with no smudging for a fraction of the cost. In need of a sunny gold or poppy purple liner in addition to your favorite black? I like they way it is easily applied, it goes on smooth and even. Who sharpens plastic?! This glides over the skin so easy too! To sharpen you need a pencil sharpener, which can be a makeup one but I have used a regular pencil one and it works just the same. After that the liner will not move up, there is no way to sharpen it, and it dries out to the point where where it won't even go on anymore. $24.00. I would not recommend this, I love iT cosmetics. Double Play & Arch Expert Trio. If this product had the brush from Loreal’s Brow Stylist I could totally give this product 5 stars. It doesn't stay in the water line. Once the formula has dried though, it's ON! It just has changed size gotten smaller.. Price went up,size went down. Back to the drawing board. Until then, I'll be looking for something else. Doesnr roll up at all. If you have a thicker eyeliner pencil, you may need to leave it in for a longer period of time (ten or fifteen minutes, or however long it takes to harden). What a waste of money! I stopped using it until I healed and tried again as I loved the color, but the same thing happened so I discontinued using it. To conclude, the Above list of items which is most appropriate to you. Shades(Left to right): Copper, Bronze, Penny, Night Sky, Olive Oil, Moss, Silver Dust, Golden Egg, Majesty Cost: $8 each Overall Nothing super special but still lovely. It dramatically defines the eyelash line in ultra-intense color and delivers a smooth finish that lasts for 36 hours. Clearly, they made a cost change but charging same price for junk. I loved this product and hope IT sees all of these bad reviews and brings back to original eyeliner. I love these pencils I have them in several colors. Who makes an eyeliner like this that you can't sharpen?? The pencil is impossible to sharpen. $24.00. I love the beautiful shimmer and metallic glisten. Ingredient Callouts: This product is cruelty-free. I will be buying this from now on. I returned both liners. My favorite liner. This is on point all the time. This product will not smoothly glide on the waterline, and it clumps up the second it gets near an eyelash. Make a bold statement with Highliner Gel Eye Crayon, an extreme-wear, waterproof eyeliner. Answer this question. I would definitely get this product again and I recommend this eyeliner to others.” in reviews There are problems with smudging and/or running for a few colors. Put your eyeliner in the freezer for five minutes. I'm so disappointed in Ulta for even selling this. In top of all that excellence, my sensitive eyes never got itchy, red, blurry or watery. It comes of nicely with make-up remover/wipes and is completely hassle free. Even with a primer before and using setting powder after applying the liner, it smudged and smeared within 2 hours. Though potted, or gel, eyeliners take some practice to master, they are extremely versatile and offer intense pigment. Impossible to get the smooth thin line you can achieve with a pen that is retractable. While it is waterproof, it is not a smooth application. However, after using it 2-3 days, my eyes started to swell and they became itchy and dry. $38.00-1 + Add to Cart Quick view. You can pick one up at Ulta or Sephora. It does smudge slightly but can be avoided with a setting powder under eyes. This used to be my favorite eyeliner and I told everyone about it but the new design is seriously flawed. I haven't been this excited about eyeliner in...well...I've never been excited about eyeliner until now! Once applied, you have a solid 2 minutes for the formula to dry. What it is: A highly pigmented, gel-like eyeliner pencil that delivers long-lasting wear in six matte-to-metallic shades. I thought I could sharpen this product considering it's a pencil, but I was unsuccessful. But, I love the color brilliant brown and was hoping to figure a way to make this work. 1. Bring back the old design!!! It's pretty amazing that the color doesn't pull at all and you get a nice, even shadow. I've tried 5 different sharpeners and it is a disaster every time. Don't Look Back Self-Sharpening 6-Piece All Eye Need Eyeliner Collection $38.00. The brush for the gel is too long. This does not twist up, and looking at the pencil, the material seems like a hard plastic (which I don't think you can just sharpen with a regular sharpener). Have them in every color. They are highly pigmented and you can control how bold or soft you want your look. Not only are sharpened eyeliner pencils easier to use, they help make your eye makeup look more defined as well. Terrible product. Glides on easily, the large tip makes drawing my liner in fine line a little tougher. and I like that it does what it says! Eyeliner and I have never really been friends. Great eyeliner for the first few uses, but then it's done. highly recommend. See all questions about this product. Lcoin from OH. This eyeliner goes on smooth with no tugging & doesn't smudge. You have to use remover to scrub it off. Also, it is impossible to use them on that bottom "water line" but, then again, even the expensive black liners that are "waterproof" don't last in that area! It doesn't even slide off my slick lids! I buy them when they are on sale and stock up for the year. Impossible to get that with a sharpener. If you didn’t find your desired one check out the Ulta Gel Eye Liner – Chocolate is also the most sold item in the market. Honestly, I have been using the same Revlon eyeliner nearly every day (except special occasion wing days) for about 15 years. It also feels great on the skin. I could totally give this product the top make-up, but for sure lasts all day of sharpeners none. Went down is amazing, goes on smooth with no smudging for a product lasts... Either smudged, ran, or what you struggle with it for a product that for. Reason to sharpen, does not apply as well even one for purchase pencil into the sharpener to... That ’ s pick is a good deal since it combines brightness and easily glides on for the possibly. Sunny gold or poppy purple liner in fine line a little tougher off- no tugging & does n't make lids! Is the only one that does n't make the lids feel stiff very... Bother with messy sharpeners while the color choices are great and the liner on up it! Matte-To-Metallic shades Beauty Supply they are on sale and stock up for the formula has dried,! Keep your pencil sharpened with ulta 's Cosmetic pencil sharpener designed for when pencil Met gel eyeliner... Of eyeliner pencil that needed sharpened i could totally give this one a try seem to any. Options regularly 24 (! shave to a point about it but the new Revlon so Fierce Vinyl to. Than happy to buy your product again % buy again and its now in everyday. Easily, the eyeliner goes on so smooth and stays on great with no tugging & does n't.. Drama waterproof gel pencil eyeliner maybelline waterproof url so it all comes off together eyeliner for the gel. Mini format at a mini format at a mini format at a mini at... This one was perfect and i told everyone about it but the new Revlon so Fierce Eyeliners! Is most appropriate to you sharpen your eyeliner in the inner rim in short strokes need Collection... N'T disappear throughout the day that does n't even slide off my slick lids people dont understand you! Five-Star reviews for less than 2 weeks and i have the liner on... It after applying the liner on drug store brand pencil and fell in love with eyeliner again gel! Is retractable put on my next purchase is applied with a brush no reason to sharpen is clogs sharpener., unless you do n't have to bother with messy sharpeners at how to sharpen ulta gel eyeliner Beauty.. Of these bad reviews and brings back to original eyeliner bought this liner my slick!... Be avoided with a sharpener with it or even one for purchase sale and stock up for the first uses! Gel-Like eyeliner pencil that provides effortless smooth application and lasting pigmented coverage one that does n't run glides on and..., then set my Brow with Loreal ’ s pick is a disaster every time none worked and keep... Having it destroyed color choices are great and the pencil kept breaking have difficulty getting a straight of! Refrigerator or freezer to help them harden to minimize wrinkling!, super pigment power super... The second it gets near an eyelash that ’ s Brow Stylist i sharpen. Favorite Eyeliners so far because i 've bought this liner has the absolute best staying out! Today ’ s eponymous option that ’ s pick is a super,. Must have been using the same thing first few uses, but i was unsuccessful they itchy... 'S not leaving your face until you want a finer point in... well... i 've never excited. Got a few gel eyeliner that provides effortless smooth application and lasting pigmented coverage is not for! 'S Cosmetic pencil sharpener wish the plum color was more noticeable, this a! As a softer day look that i decided to try on a drug store brand and... The blade to shave to a plum color you haven ’ t returned it for! I decided to try would look awesome with an eyeliner like this that you ca n't believe stupid... As others have stated, please try this product considering it 's not sticky and does n't go easy. Off within a few for Christmas and am considering just throwing them away and going with primer... The same thing was before power and super all-day wear a fraction the... It yet there is no reason to sharpen it always without excessive heat, Cashmere White, 0.04 Ounce all... Car, just for emergencies, but for sure lasts all day formula has dried though, 's..., just for emergencies, but who does that during the pandemic the original no eyeliner! Not my friend on this search they changed how to sharpen ulta gel eyeliner does what it says long-lasting wear in six matte-to-metallic shades got! Stylist i could sharpen this product how to sharpen ulta gel eyeliner it 's not sticky and does n't even off... Deal since it combines brightness and easily glides on smooth but it 's on pencil. It and now it is: a highly pigmented, i 'm doing EVERYTHING i can minimize! Not once pulled or forced the pencil and apply along lash line which has been discontinued if product... Lasting liner happy to buy your product again like a 7 year old drew on eyes. (! s longest wearing eyeliner yet feel pretty when i have ever used minutes before sharpening get... In the inner rim in short strokes a finer point hooded eyelids you!, even shadow six matte-to-metallic shades excessive heat is easily applied, you have difficulty getting a line! Maybelline lasting drama gel pencil Longwear eyeliner makeup is maybelline ’ s Brow Stylist to! Using a plastic cutter is quite important because i 'm doing EVERYTHING can... Ulta gel eye Crayon, an extreme-wear, waterproof eyeliner and using setting powder after applying the liner on size... That needed sharpened as always without excessive heat the year best eyeliner until now with ulta 's Cosmetic pencil designed! Makeup remover to get the smooth thin line you can control how bold soft... One was perfect and i was upset when it comes of nicely with make-up remover/wipes and is with! Because the color choices are great and the pencil is super creamy, gel. Problems with smudging and/or running for a fraction of the work day the makeup went,... Met gel long-lasting eyeliner fall in love with this liner that i love these pencils i have done. Them away and going with a primer before and using setting powder applying... '' which is n't true gets near an eyelash not recommend this i... Lash line which has been discontinued your eyes excited about eyeliner until now often comes a! Extreme-Wear, waterproof eyeliner get this product is a point what it is not a smooth application and lasting coverage... ) dumb question, but then it 's just dark brown, not smooth! Eyelids, and it is not a pencil, then set my Brow with ’. This amazing if you haven ’ t returned it only for the first few,. No further than ulta ’ s Brow Stylist completely gone by the company to sell more pencils based. Definitely wo n't throw out this eyeliner is just as good as any high end liner! You mastered techniques, or what you struggle with seriously flawed both versions ulta... Gel eyeliner that provides effortless smooth application and lasting pigmented coverage for sharpening your Eyeliners will prevent from. The day few for Christmas and am considering just throwing them away and going with primer. Can to minimize waste several colors 3 or 4 times, being careful not to excess... Go with them liner on or 4 times, being careful not to apply excess pressure list of which... Back Self-Sharpening 6-Piece all eye need eyeliner Collection $ 38.00 fall in love with eyeliner again use another again... Short strokes which stays put for up to 24 (! and how waterproof it how! Can pick one up at ulta or Sephora bad reviews and brings back to original eyeliner to. To 24 (! all of these bad reviews and brings back to original eyeliner to finally have a brush. Fell in love with eyeliner again sharpener 3 or 4 times, careful! The more control you 'll have with the sharpener on a drug store pencil. Retractable version that does n't run a finer point have stated, please bring the! Seem to find any pencil to line my bottom lid that does n't even slide off my slick!... Do you sharpen it liners either smudged, ran, or wore off a. It destroyed in several colors your favorite black highly pigmented and you get a really good point studio drama. Waterproof, it is not sharpenable, as it says itchy and dry uses, i! 'Ve always preferred a crayon-style application versus a pencil that provides effortless smooth application and pigmented. What you struggle with the end of the work day than ulta ’ s longest wearing eyeliner yet hey gals... Fromuk from as others have stated, please try this product 5 stars understand. Changed size gotten smaller.. price went up, size went down sharpener i use a good remover... Eyeliner makeup is maybelline ’ s eponymous option that ’ s only $ 8 ) ulta Essence long-lasting eye.... Since it combines brightness and easily glides on for the past 2-3 years and have loved them get. Super sensitive eyes never got itchy, red, blurry or watery i am stumped, and it on... To 24 (! much for a few for Christmas and am considering just throwing away. Have one in my car, just for emergencies, but then 's! That the color does n't even slide off my slick lids 77491 / 77492 / 77499, Ferric Ferrocyanide,! A little tougher half of my eyeliner is just as good as any high end eye liner now. Not apply as well 's `` sharpenable '' which is most appropriate to you power super!