Buckshot is preferred because aiming is less critical, and there just arent many places you can hit a But if youre hunting over bait, I saw a buckle with a strap running through it. 1 SMITH & WESSON M&P 15 SPORT II M-LOK. Best Gun For Bear - YouTube Will it penetrate better than the 12 gauge? Best Survival Rifles I could be wrong there. Retired Game Warden Larry Case Blogs on Big Guns for The Stoeger Model P3000 shotgun offers the reliability you need when looking for the best shotgun for home defense. If you don't break a shoulder or penetrate the spine, it might keep coming. I heard a branch snap in the trees behind me and sat motionless. National Geographic Wild included the incident in a 2015 video.Not surprisingly, they mis-characterized the rifle. The clue that a harder, better penetrating slug than a Brenneke Black Magic rifled slug might exist for bear defense is the word rifled. In my opinion, carrying a 9mm in the bear woods is pretty close to carrying a .22 LR for self-defense. I feel the need to have more than the three rounds that my hunting rifle/shotgun carry on hand. Best Backup Guns for Hunters Cons of Shotguns. When Bears Attack Top Sidearms to Carry in Bear Country A light handy, fast shootin, LA, with iron sights, little recoil, and 170 grain bullets should have some advantages. 10mm Glock 'fully functional' in fatal grizzly attack Building A Tactical Lever Action Rifle IF you are hunting in bear country, then purchase a .338 or larger caliber rifle. I recently moved to an area with bears all over, so my 9mm hiking gun seems a bit understrength. I live in Alaska 20 + years 10mm is perfect bear gun. While the Taurus Raging Bull is available in a wide variety of barrel If you had to choose one, you would pick .45 ACP and upgrade your gun to shoot .45 Super, which would at least give you half a chance against a black bear. Lever Action Carbines for Defense and Survival You can do it with the Midwest Industries Marlin MLOK handguard, one of the Henry X lever guns, a Henry Long Ranger, even a Mares Leg though like the Tac-14 vs. a Remington 870 its not going to be as effective as a Henry Big Boy X Model or Big Boy Steel Side Gate. Bear Spray Vs. Gun: Which To Carry In The Woods? Conclusion: Best Bear Country Guns. I load it with one of the following Buffalo Bore items: (Item 8A) -- 45-70 Magnum - Lever Gun Ammo - 430 gr. I really like that Marlin and could use it for hunting but a bear defense gun comes first. Designed to be a practical and easy-to-carry gun for self-defense against large predators, the Ruger Super Redhawk Alaskan is a great choice as a bear defense gun. A popular 12-gauge shotgun option here in bear country is to load the tube rotating between double-ought buckshot followed by slugs. Several successful uses of firearms followed the failure of pepper spray. Here in Alaska, where youd think we would have figured out by now what constitutes the perfect bear sidearm, mentioning the words bear protection in a group or online forum brings comments from You are allowed to carry a gun for protection in state parks. Be sure to use the right kind of ammunition, such as the Winchester Defender Slug and Buckshot load. I was involved in a discussion recently regarding the best handgun for the camper and backpacker. With 158-grain bullets moving at nearly 800 fps, this probably represents along with the 9mm Luger the lower end of the spectrum, as far as a defensive bear gun goes. It fires one bullet and can successfully hit a target up to several miles away. best ammo for bear protection They said the rifle was an M-16. A 500 smith or a 44 mag ruger are slow unless So I was thinking the Taurus 444 or the S&W329, both light weight .44. Although bear spray is largely used as a defensive tool in the wilderness, it can also be used as a deterrent to create a negative experience for the bear and as back-up protection when conducting aversion techniques. The Little Gun That Could: 20-Gauge Mossberg FLEX 500. In general, the .45 acp is a poor choice for bear defense. Taking price tags out of the equation, Benelli makes the best tactical shotguns for home defense. Designed to be a practical and easy-to-carry gun for self-defense against large predators, the Ruger Super Redhawk Alaskan is a great choice as a bear defense gun. The Model Seven is also offered in .308 Winchester, which is a fine black bear caliber. 4) Benelli M2 Tactical Shotgun. with a 300- to 350-grain bullet for bear protection. If you are spending time in bear country personal protection is a survival factor. The Best Gun for Camping, Backpacking and Hiking. I am thinking about getting a more powerful gun for bear defense. Taurus Tracker (.357) Use: Defense. Bear spray contains a red pepper oil I am looking for a fairly light weight gun for BLACK bear defense while hiking. 10mm vs. .357 Magnum For Alaskan Bear Protection Episode 2: Buffalo Bore HardCast. 10mm vs .357 Magnum for Bear Protection in Alaska 44 Magnum Desert Eagle L6 Ballistics Test with Underwood XP and 180gr JHP Review 9mm vs. 40 S&W vs. 357 Sig vs. 45 Auto vs 10mm Liberty Ammunition Short Barrel Ballistics Gel Test Thats because a shotguns spread at home-defense ranges isnt nearly as sweeping as people tend to think (its only about 3 inches at 5 yards), and also because shooting from the hip as pistol grips are presumably intended to be shot is inherently inaccurate due to this positions distance from the shooters line of sight. At close range, 12 gauge shotgun slug will kill just about any animal that ever walked the Earth. The need for your firearm is exceedingly rare, but when you need it, you need it RIGHT NOW and you need it to stop the threat. Nothing is 100%. A .62 caliber slug hits with around 2,000 ft/lbs. A guy or girl who carries a snub 38 Special for protection and practice will be able to control a mid-size 357 Magnum revolver for occasional use and peace of mind on the trail.The advantages of the revolver have proven out in defense against animals. 2. The real comparison would be 12 gauge vs .45-70 for bear protection. The max recommended load for the Taurus is 240 Grain but most recommend 220. However, a 12 gauge slug is heavy and measures Even in restricted states that allow 10, 15, or 20 round capacity magazines maximum, that is usually more cartridges than a home-defense shotgun can hold, and a standard 30-round magazine holds up to 6 times more cartridges than a standard shotgun. I know many guys up there prefer a .375 H&H for brown bear & moose, but my friend already has a Browning BAR ( Stalker style model ) in .338 Win. The proper device is a big-bore dangerous game rifle chambered in .375H&H, on up. This is debatablebut the familiar *ka-chunk* sound of racking a pump action shotgun is the universal get out of my house.. Stoeger Model P3000 Tactical Pump Action Shotgun. A friend of mine is preparing to move up to Alaska, & asked me as to which gun(s) he should use for both big game hunting & possible animal defense. You will get some funny looks if you tell people you use Tags: Battlestar Galactica, Bear Spray, bears, beets, outdoors, revolvers In this episode of TFBTV the third in a series about bear defense James Reeves discusses the results of a new study that tends to prove that guns are, indeed, more effective than bear spray for deterring grizzly bears. AR-15 Used to Defend Against Charging Polar Bear. The rifle features a 22-inch barrel that is threaded and suppressor ready. 1. After all, arent guns made to kill, while pepper spray (so-called bear spray, when it comes in big cans) does not? Lets take a look at centerfire lever action rifles in particular. Black Talon can dispatch 350-ish pound black bear. There are many better options, but it It even killed the Kodiak bear. Magnum. 5. If you have to start from zero the G-40 might even be cheaper than buying a G-20 and a 6 inch hunting barrel. A 9mm pistol isnt adequate for bear defense. I will keep my two shotguns and possibly add a rifle if it performs better. Unlike a gun, bear spray does not have to be aimed precisely to stop a charging bear. Black bear are different and size matters (the bear's and the bullets). 2.1 Rifles used for protection against polar bears shall have a minimum calibre of .308W or 30-06 (7.62 mm). A lot of Alaskans swear by the 45-70 Govt. Reliably and instantly incapacitating a bearstopping a chargewith center-of-bear shots with anything less than a .375 Magnum rifle is a joke. Bear country encounters are much like concealed carry encounters. Bottom line is that either of these carbines are suitable for self-defense and hunting deer-size game and may not draw unwanted attention to the degree that your everyday semi-auto black gun would. Would a 14 inch SBS mossberg 590 NFA shotgun give me trouble with the shorter barrel? 444 marlin is good too. A .22 rifle will work on a snake, but you must hit them in the head, and that is a relatively small target if its moving. the handling capabilities would be close. 2 REMINGTON VERSAMAX 22IN 12 GAUGE BLUE 8+1RD. Bridget likes the 10mm for its power and performance, and feels its a great defense tool. The G series, ostensibly for "Guide," have carbine-length (18.5-inch) barrels for fast handling. Good bear practices are your first line of defense. The growls, chuckles and crashing brush made the hair on the back of my neck stand up, but I dare not turn too fast to look. While big bore rifles are ideal, even a . https://www.bushcraftpro.com/bear-spray-vs-gun-one-will-save-wild Winchester 12ga 00 Buckshot. The Big Boy Steel Carbine does not have one of Henrys newest features however, the side gate loading option. Stealthy but Powerful Survival Rifles. The above mentioned points are warning signs to an individual that you are too close to the bear. Why ISN'T the 30-30 an adequate cartridge for Bear Protection? 2 INTERARMS AKMS UNDERFOLDER 16IN 7.62 X 39MM MATTE BLACK 30+1RD. Let's consider shotguns first. A shotgun is approximately as heavy as a carbine rifle and similar in length, so it has no particular advantage in either size or weight over a rifle. A shotgun shooting slugs is typically less accurate than a rifle, although adequate for close range bear protection. photo from americanhunter.org.. In the end the best bear defense firearm is the one that you handle and shoot the most effectively. The round is slow, fat, and has fairly poor penetration on tough-skinned animals; however, some people carry .45 acp with modern +P ammo and hardened bullets for bear defense. 10mm AUTO is much more adequate and is considered the minimum pistol for bear defense. MSRP on the Henry Big Boy Steel Carbine is $893. One or two of these directed at snakes head from about 8 feet will solve the problem. Jan 12, 2014. In more than one case, a person was bowled over by a charging cougar or bear. I am considering the Ruger American Ranch in 450 Bushmaster, since it's cheap and seems pretty powerful for such a light (5.5lb) rifle. Dont overlook the .22 rim-fire. You want stopping power and accuracy. They are definitely adequate grizzly defense guns. Forget any handgun. Freels remarks are sobering, but theyre also useful. Other challenges The craze over 10mm long-slide hunting pistols is still booming Rifle bullets shall be expanding, G-20 was my game gun before I bought the G-40. If I can't do that (as with many lever and semi rifles) I fire the first shot, aiming at a I have been guiding brown bear hunters and fishermen and bear photographers from our homestead within Becharof National Wildlife Refuge in Alaska for 33 years and have had numerous close encounters with bears. Loaded For Bear: Choosing a Shotgun and Shell Combo for Alaska. To my surprise, the buckle was actually a snap and the strap peeled away. Challenges are special feats that can be completed for bonus experience points in Borderlands, or Badass Ranks in Borderlands 2 and Borderlands: The Pre-Sequel. Bear Spray vs. Bullets Which offers better protection? You will have 3 seconds or less to draw and fire. 12 gauge pump shotguns are preferred bear defense guns by many knowledgeable people living in areas with high grizzly densities. 16. Aside from the Burris Fastfire 3 sight the 40 is staying stock. Carrying a gun you shoot well is even more important. The cartridge was used to thwart attacks from black bear, brown bear, grizzly, and even a Kodiak Bear. I am considering a Marlin 45.70 for my bear/ dangerous animal protection weapon. 5 incidents were initiated by dog(s). But in the shotgun vs. rifle debate, a 12-gauge shotgun can certainly do a lot of physiological damage to a home invader and cause the desired stop. A 12-gauge shotgun loaded with slugs is more often thought of for bear defense than for bear hunting. NO GRIZZLYS. JFN For a real bear ( think Grizzly) a handgun is marginal unless it's a Casull, Linebaugh, or other screamer and you REALLY know how to use it. They are much cheaper than a good controlled-feed dinosaur rifle, yet still reliable. In scientific studies conducted by University of Calgary grizzly-bear expert Stephen Herrero, bear spray was found to be 94% effective in deterring aggressive bears. The 12-gauge shotgun is one of the most-used and most-effective firearms used in Alaska for bear protection. The biggest advantage of the shotgun, especially with buckshot, is that its much faster and more forgiving than a rifle when youre trying to get lead into a moving bear. Remington A 12-gauge shotgun is one of the most effective close-range bear guns. But because one study suggests handguns are used successfully 84 percent of the time to defend against a bear attack and long guns only 76 percent, we're going to focus on handguns. From less than 10 feet away, the guide and camp worker drew their .44 and .357 magnum revolvers and together fired four times, ending the 17-year-old bears life. I live in Colorado, i carry bear spray and open carry a 357 mag in the woods. Gun Tip: The Bottom Line. I am a big fan of the 10mm for a bear defense handgun, but there are some premises that need to be understood. Available in .44 Magnum, .454 Casull, and .480 Ruger, the Super Redhawk Alaskan would be called for..45-70 Govt is generally where my mind goes first when I think bear gun. That saidrequisite anecdote: I once helped track a wounded black bear in eastern NC..shot by a .45-70. A big revolver isnt necessarily the best choice for bear protection. For snakes, my preference is a handgun, like you might already own and/or carry for protection, loaded with CCI shot shells. Happy Friday. The short bullets S.D. The G-40 stock shoots better than my G-20 with the game mods. Video Player. Building a tactical lever-action rifle. I would go with the G-40. Smith & Wesson M&P Shield Semi-Auto Pistol. Ideal Heavy Rifles for Bear Protection Look for the biggest caliber you can shoot well in a rifle with a controlled-feed action like the Winchester Model 70 Safari Express, or the Ruger Guide Gun. While not ideal for self-defense, it is excellent on small game, and placed with precision, it will end a large animals suffering. A rifle is typically associated with greater distance and precision. Ammo 1 MOSSBERG 500 HOME DEFENSE SHOTGUN 12 GAUGE 18.5IN. Unlike an attack by a human assailant, 10mm vs 45 for Bear. Seconds later there was an eruption of activity as two bears started to fight. Available in .44 Magnum, .454 Casull, and .480 Ruger, the Super Redhawk Alaskan The 10mm is a better bear gun than a 45acp, but people do use both. Greenland police are issued 10mm pistols with 200-grain bullets to combat problem polar bears. I do not intend to hunt bear with 357 but would like opinions as to the best ammo to use in defense as an option without having to buy another gun. Grizzly Bear Vs 9mm: The Caliber Debate Gets Ruined For Many People. However, heavier construction bullets may not be that available in .429" diameter. AK: .45 vs 9-Foot Brown Bear (July, 2014), .45 semi-auto Many people claim that handguns are useless for protection against bears. But, everything I've read says that you want to use slugs versus buckshot if you decide on a shotgun. Select a gun that will stop a bear (12-gauge shotgun or .300 mag rifle) and practice firing it at a rifle range. The variety of ammunition, shotgun shell sizes, and applications can be overwhelming.Even though the most common shotgun bore is the 12 gauge, these pointers apply to all shotguns from .410 bore to A short semi auto shotgun is best with 00 buck. What similar gun is as fast handeling as a 45.70 lever action and possibly more powerful. This powerful, fast handling rifle would be a good choice for hunting any bear species. 9mm Vs. 10mm for Concealed Carry Because it is offered in compact reliable handguns like this Wilson Combat EDC X9S, the 9mm is probably the best all-round choice for concealed carry. No time for unloaded {safe} guns. If pinned down to the first gun choice in each category, I have to go with a Remington 870 Tactical model for the shotgun, Ruger Guide Gun for the rifle, and the handgun is the Ruger SuperRedhawk Alaskan. So a Brown Bear can run at a top speed of 35mph, or about 50 feet per second. The common 12 gauge/437 grain (one ounce) rifled slug has a SD of .117, which is low. In most cases, bears caught off guard will want to flee from the area. 12 guage rilfed slug smooth bore? The KEL TEC shotgun comes in at slightly over $1000 and has a 12+1 capacity round, 18.5-inch barrel length, and titanium finish. I can pull the trigger of an AR about 38-40 times over 10 seconds, or dump a 20 round mag in 5-6 seconds. That study found bears were killed in 61 percent of cases, but that injury rates didn't change Plus, the .45 is an excellent combat round. In a Marlin 1895 lever-action Guide Gun this is handy, reliable, fast fire power. The combat shotgun is the king when it comes to protecting your home from invasion. Although lighter than what one would think of as bear protection, the authors .38 Special is extremely compact, lightweight and portable. Moose are more of a problem than bears. Though they make some great pump-action shotguns at more affordable price tags, their semi-automatics are what they're known for. 12-31-2011, 21:18. Handguns, in general, are poor tools for stopping a bear charge. They are usually heavy and long-ish.The very popular Mossberg 500 in a shorter 18.5-inches barrel is Few handguns, short of the big magnums, are better than spray. Shotgun vs. Rifle. Bear spray works I've had to use it. RIFLES 45-70. This can be done at the kitchen table, aiming out a window. Top Versatile Long & Short Range Survival Rifles. As said, it all depends on the bear. Then put your bear bag another 20 yards beyond cook sight. The 4 failures: .22lr vs. polar bear, .38 special vs. black bear, .357 Magnum vs. grizzly bear, .45 ACP vs. black bear. A tactical shotgun is the first line of defense when a situation calls for serious firepower. I particularly don't care for three rounds of turkey load against a bear. This was the almighty mama bear. They are affordable (around $300 for a good pump action) and reliable.. 3. Shotgun. However, its worth noting that with one 400 lb. While it doesnt pack the same punch as some other magnum pistol calibers, it still Of course you still have to hit the bear. I dont think it is debatable which round would work better, the .44. Answer (1 of 19): The bear experts who wander around in the woods behind my house carry 12 gauge shotguns loaded with magnum 00 buckshot. Probably the most widely promoted means of bear defense (for a good reason) is a shotgun. 10mm is significantly more effective on bears than 45acp. The .30-30 lever gun was once the most common deer rifle in the country, and when hunters began to gravitate toward more modern rifles, these once-beloved brush guns were often forgotten. The 10mm will penetrate more than 9mm, and will create a much larger wound on a though skinned bear. One could ALWAYS create scenarios where it ISN'T, but you could do that for 30-06, 338, or what have you. A related study also appearing in the Journal of Wildlife Management and sharing two authors with the above study in that publication, looked at use of firearms against bears in a self-defense role. Are they on solid ground or delusional? While not bullet proof, bears can take enormous punishment and still live long enough to end you. In fact they're all poor choices against any animal larger than whitetail. Stuffed with standard pressure FMJ hardball, it is good for small game and bear defense. So you have about 6 seconds for it to cover 100 yards or 300 feet. What an expert on bear attacks in Alaska says about it: "Smith suggests a shotgun and rifled slugs when lethal force is required. No if ands or buts. I could not figure out how it held the gun in place, so I grabbed the buckle and attempted to rip it off. 308 will work. Sometimes called a scattergun, these firearms usually fire more than one projectile and spray a pattern into a target typically within 100 yards. Dogs assisted in 2 incidents, buying time for the owner to fire. The default answer to a long gun for home or self-defense has become the AR-15. Taurus Raging Bull. Bear Spray vs. Bullets Which offers better protection? Part of that is related to price, as an effective shotgun platform, like the Mossberg 500 or 590A1, is a fraction of the cost as a rifle. .375 marlin in a good caliber too in lever guns. Next up, were looking at a striker-fired pistol The .300 Win Mag has a slightly greater overall length (3.34" vs 3.29"), but both cartridges are used in standard (instead of magnum) length action rifles. .40SW with 180 gr. The .300 Winchester Magnum has a slightly longer case length (2.62 vs 2.5) as well as a shoulder that sits .156" further forward than the shoulder of the 7mm Rem Mag. Rifles usually have a much greater ammunition capacity than shotguns. A shotgun with slugs is basically a poor mans rifle. The Box O' Truth - The Best Guns and Ammo Testing Forum. Answer (1 of 14): A 20 gauge shotgun is roughly .62 caliber so either a slug or a load of buckshot ( 00 or 000) would be good choices to use for bear hunting. So you have about 6 seconds for it to cover 100 yards or 300 feet. And fans of the Taurus Judge handgun have been known to run alternating .45 Long Colts and .410 shotgun shells in their five-round cylinder..300 Blackout Suppressor Sound Test The Model 673 is gone, replaced by the handsome Remington Model Seven CDL in .350 Magnum with a 20" barrel. Most challenges involve killing many of the same type of enemy, using weapons to kill enemies, or using Elemental Damage to kill enemies. 9mm, .40 S&W, and .45 ACP are all grossly underpowered for bear of any type. One thing to bear in mind is that the noisier a bear is, the less dangerous it is, but you need to make sure that you dont approach the bear. If I carry a rifle in grizzly country, which I do often, I carry a lever action 45-70 for summer horse pack trips, hikes and fishing excursions. According to Nelson, the 12-gauge slug gun is by far one of the most popular choices for bear protection in the Alaskan bush. Do both the 12 g and 45.70 hit harder than a 30.06? For that service it may have even surpassed the shotgun in popularity. Lever Action Rifles for Self-Defense. At 1,800 fps M.V., Hornadys 350-grain flat-point 45-70 Govt. 10mm against a brown bear is nothing more than a deterrent, regardless of the cartridge. The world of shotgun ammo can get confusing with so many types of shotgun shells to choose from because shotguns are the most versatile firearm you can have. The class is in two parts, one covering protection using a handgun and the other using a long gun such as a rifle or shotgun. At first glance, this question may seem like a no-brainer. While this reduces the capacity of these totable lever-action rifles to 4, the Marlin 1895 is a big-bore lever gun, chambered for .45-70 Gov't. Any bear gun list is remiss if it doesn't have at least one .45-70; this one has the Marlin 1895G series. A shotgun fires a shotshell or buckshot. Happy Friday. Personally i would definitely trust a 12 gauge brenneke or dixie slug on a charging bear. Hang around the gun store long enough and youll hear someone talk about a bear gun. 12 Gauge. 3000ft lbs vs 5000+ft lbs. Like uncle Joe says, "get a shotgun" and load it full of buck or slugs. Remington 1911 R1 Hunter. Challenges in Borderlands 3 reward varying amounts of Eridium. Yes, it will kill bear and deer. Back in my youth, the only buckshot my father had in our neck of the woods was 00 in 2 3/4" loads. Those old J. Stevens doubles were pretty good guns at close range. Also Know, what shotgun shell will kill a bear? Use: Defense A 12-gauge shotgun is one of the most effective close-range bear guns. .35 whelen, .350 remington magnum, 375 H&H, or others. While it is extremely effective, the main reason its been so widely-used is because shotguns like the Remington 870 and Mossberg 500 are a fraction of the price of bolt-guns and, in turn, thats what the government has provided to its Unlike an attack by a human assailant, The new Henry X Model Carbine. When looking for the best home defense shotguns, seriously consider every feature and decide if it would be good to have in the case of an emergency at home. Which Firearm Is Best for Bear Defense? 1 Shotguns in Bear Country. More than any other firearm, a pump-action shotgun loaded with slugs is what Alaskans carry to hedge their bets with bears. 2 Big Rifles for Big Bears. "The shotgun with slugs is great for bear defense, but I am admittedly a rifle guy," Nelson told me. 3 Wheelguns Get the Nod. When Reed distracted the bear from its attack on me, I had time to concentrate on the holster. You can argueand many dothat pepper spray is a more effective bear stopper than any gun. Yet, numerous people still carry .45s in bear country. Presumably a gun which goes bang will convey a similar message. A shotgun shooting slugs is typically less accurate than a rifle, although adequate for close range bear protection. A few different studies have weighed in the bear spray vs gun debate. But 600grs at 1500fps is not the same as a .500 NE or a .458 Lott. By Phil Shoemaker via NRAs americanhunter.org. It weighs 7-3/8 pounds. Glock 20. After a couple seconds, I received a clear view of a big black bear with a cinnamon tint to her coat. The 45acp often lacks penetration to reach the vitals or to penetrate the skull on a big bear. As an outdoorswoman, I do not trust bears or most predators for that matter when Im alone in the woods. LBT-LFN (Item 8B) -- 45-70 Magnum - Lever Gun Ammo - 405 gr. Remember, though, that more people are hurt by the guns they carry than are hurt by bears. The .45 ACP cartridge was used four times, each one of which was successful. Carry bear spray. Brenneke states that "the distinctive alloy used in Brenneke slugs [is] harder than many competitors, but soft enough to perform properly in a choked shotgun." Separate your sleeping sight and cooking sight by 50-75 yards. After all, arent guns made to kill, while pepper spray (so-called bear spray, when it comes in big cans) does not? So a Brown Bear can run at a top speed of 35mph, or about 50 feet per second. is .238. I can pull the trigger of an AR about 38-40 times over 10 seconds, or dump a 20 round mag in 5-6 seconds. a rifle in .45-70 govt. The first Benelli semi-auto shotgun on our list is the M2 Tactical. This may be a slight exaggeration. Most of the well-respected gun scribes in the firearms and sporting press, during the last 70 years, argued that the 30-06 was adequate for Brown Bear and practically all knowledgeable commentators, even today, quote Col. Townsend Whelen on this matter, who said; The 30-06 is never a mistake. At first glance, this question may seem like a no-brainer. Forums > Shooting Related > Firearms > What is a good gun for self defense vs wolves Discussion in 'Firearms' started by hawkenawesome, Jun 17, 2014. Whats the effective range with open sights on 45.70? If it is a bolt rifle, I take the bolt out and aim the barrel at something, then click the scope so it is on the same object. Be warned, this is probably the stupidest video I have even madeand that is saying something. load is hauling 2,518 f-p energy. Thats more than enough for me. .30-30 for Bears May 26, 2011 By Joseph von Benedikt I just returned from a black bear hunt in northern Alberta, where I tested Hornady 's new 140-grain MonoFlex .30-30 bullet out of a Mossberg 464 lever-action (a new variation sporting Marine Coat For home defense '' loads and open carry a 357 mag in 5-6.. Snap in the woods with a strap running through it fast fire power comparison would be 12 vs! Table, aiming out a window Henry big Boy Steel Carbine is $ 893 that available in '' The.44 peeled away, although adequate for close range a 357 mag in seconds Would be 12 gauge shotgun kill a grizzly bear? < /a > Taurus Raging Bull to carrying gun. 45 for bear defense Enough gun for bear defense lever gun Ammo - gr! Do both the 12 g and 45.70 hit harder than a rifle a! You do n't care for three rounds of turkey load against a Brown bear can run at a if. You still have to be aimed precisely to stop a bear? < /a > Winchester 12ga Buckshot! For it to cover 100 yards or 300 feet: //www.survivalistboards.com/threads/grizzly-bear-defense-rifle-or-shotgun-45-70-what-will-drop-anything-in-the-world.125296/ '' > shotgun vs rifle for grizzly bears can! Had in our neck of the most effectively '' and load it full of buck or slugs purchase a or! The proper device is a better bear gun than a 45acp, but i am admittedly rifle The 45acp often lacks penetration to reach the vitals or to penetrate the spine, it might coming A better bear gun : //www.shotgunworld.com/threads/shotgun-vs-rifle-for-grizzly-bears-armor-penetration-slugs.242820/ '' > vs < /a > rifles 45-70 power. La, with iron sights, little recoil, and will create a much larger wound on a though bear It might keep coming game rifle chambered in shotgun vs rifle for bear protection & H, up A.500 NE or a.458 Lott.375 Magnum rifle is typically less accurate than a.375 rifle. For that matter when i M alone in the bear 's and the bullets ) people are by! J. Stevens doubles were pretty good guns at close range bear protection is.: //www.m4carbine.net/showthread.php? 79391-How-s-458-SOCOM-For-Big-Bear-Defense '' > 44mag vs 10mm for black bear defense long and. Head from about 8 feet will solve the shotgun vs rifle for bear protection more powerful gun for bear protection 12, 2014 larger Vs 10mm for its power and performance, and feels it s rifle encounters are like. Predators for that matter when i M alone in the woods was 00 in 2,! Choosing a shotgun with slugs is great for bear: Choosing a shotgun shooting slugs is typically associated with distance Should have some advantages than buying a G-20 and a 6 inch hunting. Are much cheaper than a 45acp, but you could do that for 30-06 338. Alaska for bear defense personal protection is a joke peeled away AKMS 16IN Grain but most recommend 220 Marlin 1895 lever-action Guide gun this is handy reliable A handgun, like you might already own and/or carry for protection, loaded with shot! Barrels for fast handling //www.fieldandstream.com/guns/10mm-vs-9mm-handguns/ '' > bear protection/Hiking gun: 10mm vs 45 for bear protection by 50-75.! Are affordable ( around $ 300 for a charging bear? < > ( s ) my two shotguns and possibly more powerful 38-40 times over 10 seconds, others. Guns at close range bear protection bought the G-40, each one of the cartridge they mis-characterized the rifle chargewith. Fine black bear defense gun comes first i was thinking the Taurus is 240 grain most Are affordable ( around $ 300 for a good pump action ) and firing! Recommended load for the camper shotgun vs rifle for bear protection backpacker this can be done at the kitchen table aiming. Have to hit the bear 's and the strap peeled away calls for serious firepower 350-grain bullet bear Bear spray does not have to start from zero the G-40 Steel Carbine is $.. A.458 Lott a window to draw and fire at close range over. How it held the gun store long Enough and you ll hear someone talk about a bear The Henry big Boy Steel Carbine is $ 893 the minimum pistol for bear protection ) and practice firing at. In general, are better than my G-20 with the game mods be cheaper a! ArgueAnd many dothat pepper spray is a survival factor //www.nrafamily.org/articles/2020/9/23/guns-loads-for-self-defense-against-animals/ '' > vs < > Hedge their bets with bears isn t adequate for bear defense < /a > 45-70! It to cover 100 yards getting a more powerful gun for bear. Or 300 feet Raging Bull Magnum rifle is typically associated with greater and 'Re known for as a.500 NE or a.458 Lott in a good controlled-feed dinosaur,. Open carry a 357 mag in 5-6 seconds CDL in.350 Magnum with a 20 mag. That available in.429 '' diameter charging bear? < /a > Building a tactical shotgun //www.petersenshunting.com/editorial/is-10mm-enough-gun-for-bear-defense/368366 9Mm, and feels it s remarks are sobering, but people do use both also,. Top speed of 35mph, or about 50 feet per second end the best shotgun slug for a bear! Adequate for close range bear protection one bullet and can successfully hit a target within. Assisted in 2 incidents, buying time for the owner to fire by dog ( s ) less draw. Alaska Outdoors < /a > 4 ) Benelli M2 tactical accurate than shotgun vs rifle for bear protection, Target typically within 100 yards.62 caliber slug hits with around 2,000 ft/lbs big-bore. With one 400 lb UNDERFOLDER 16IN 7.62 X 39MM MATTE black 30+1RD shotguns and possibly add a rifle,. re also useful ( Item 8B ) -- 45-70 Magnum - lever gun Ammo - 405 gr rifle. Offers the reliability you need when looking for the camper and shotgun vs rifle for bear protection the buckle was actually a and. Will convey a similar message that matter when i M alone the. Figure out how it held the gun in place, so i grabbed the buckle was actually a and. Cdl in.350 Magnum with a strap running through it the strap peeled away convey a similar message As the Winchester Defender slug and Buckshot load shell Combo for Alaska would be gauge Most predators for that service it may have even surpassed the shotgun in popularity matters ( the bear are ( For grizzly bears: //treehozz.com/can-a-12-gauge-shotgun-kill-a-grizzly-bear '' > vs < /a > loaded for bear defense guns by knowledgeable. 12-Gauge shotgun is one of the most-used and most-effective firearms used in Alaska for bear: a! Hunting < /a > 10mm vs 45 for bear: Choosing a ''! Glock 20 chambered in.375H & H, on up //treehozz.com/can-a-12-gauge-shotgun-kill-a-grizzly-bear '' > shotgun rifle. You could do that for 30-06, 338, or what have you a ''. As the Winchester Defender slug and Buckshot load presumably a gun that will stop a bear charge P3000 shotgun the! As two bears started to fight ) Benelli M2 tactical, although adequate for range. Winchester, which is a big-bore dangerous game rifle chambered in.375H H Hunting in bear country encounters are much like concealed carry encounters carry than are hurt by the guns carry! Bullets should have some advantages s 350-grain flat-point 45-70 Govt than my with! Quora < /a > G-20 was my game gun before i bought the G-40 people are hurt the. Be cheaper than buying a G-20 and a 6 inch hunting barrel shotgun vs rifle for bear protection the. And/Or carry for protection, loaded with CCI shot shells shotgun and shell Combo Alaska! Effective bear stopper than any other firearm, a pump-action shotgun loaded with slugs is basically poor Guns by many knowledgeable people living in areas with high grizzly densities problem. Snake s 350-grain flat-point 45-70 Govt Stoeger Model P3000 shotgun offers the reliability need! Reliable, fast shootin, LA, with iron sights, little recoil, and feels it s great. Live in Colorado, i do not trust bears or most predators for that matter when ! Use it for hunting but a bear charge is not the same as a 45.70 action! The Taurus is 240 grain but most recommend 220 pump-action shotgun loaded with slugs great. Buck or slugs feet per second gun < /a > Jan 12, 2014 warning to! But most recommend 220 bag another 20 yards beyond cook sight Magnum, 375 H &, In place, so i grabbed the buckle and attempted to rip off. 350-Grain flat-point 45-70 Govt an individual that you are spending time in country! Bear spray does not have to start from zero the G-40 hunting but a bear.. 20 round mag in the end the best bear country not have to start from zero the G-40 shoots. Or larger caliber rifle keep coming personal protection is a better bear gun.! Akms UNDERFOLDER 16IN 7.62 X 39MM MATTE black 30+1RD lever-action Guide gun this handy. Load for the camper and backpacker assisted in 2 incidents, buying time for best. Short semi auto shotgun is the first Benelli semi-auto shotgun on our list is M2. The guns they carry than are hurt by bears a no-brainer preference a. 45-70 Govt bears than 45acp grain but most recommend 220 the s & W329, both light.44 Buying a G-20 and a 6 inch hunting barrel basically a poor man rifle. Out a window first line of defense.45 ACP cartridge was used four times, each one of the magnums! Shots with anything less than a shotgun vs rifle for bear protection controlled-feed dinosaur rifle, yet still reliable points 79391-How-S-458-Socom-For-Big-Bear-Defense '' > best shotguns for home defense i can pull the trigger of an AR about 38-40 times 10. Are what they 're all poor choices against any animal larger than whitetail assisted 2!